Covid-19 Evaluation

Alone

1
CHY 8259
RCN 20020057
5 September 2025

Dear Professor Anne Scott,

ALONE welcomes the opportunity to contribute to the COVID-19 Evaluation, which seeks to assess
the impact of the pandemic’s management in Ireland.

The effects of COVID-19 across Ireland were particularly severe for older people, who experienced
disproportionately high infection and mortality. Individuals over the age of 65 accounted for 92% of
all confirmed COVID-19 deaths in Ireland and more than 26% of confirmed cases 1. Further analysis
revealed that 14% of all cases occurred among those aged 80+, despite representing just 3% of the
population.

ALONE is a national organisation dedicated to supporting older people to age at home. Demand for
our services rose dramatically during the pandemic. In 2019, we supported 5,410 older people with
the help of 2,146 volunteers. By the end of 2020, with additional Government support, we had
expanded to serve 14,800 older people and established the National Support and Referral Line
(NSRL) in partnership with the Department of Health and the HSE. The NSRL operates seven days a
week, twelve hours per day, providing vital information, referrals, and emotional support. Since the
onset of the pandemic, our services have continued to grow, supporting 43,900 older people
nationwide in 2024 through Support Coordination, Visitation and Telephone Support and
Befriending services, Technology initiatives, and Housing supports, in collaboration with statutory,
voluntary, and community partners.

ALONE also took significant actions at Government level to help older people during the pandemic.
ALONE CEO Seán Moynihan was a member of the COVID-19 NPHET Subgroup for Vulnerable People
and held meetings with Taoiseach Leo Varadkar and Minister of Health Simon Harris to discuss
supports for older people. In addition to establishing the NSRL, ALONE partnered with each
COVID-19 Community Response Forum and Community Call helplines run by local authorities1.
NSRL details were published widely, including in the COVID-19 public information booklet delivered
to every
household in the State2 although this happened without the level of planning that this type of
change would typically require.

While this submission does not focus on nursing homes, we would also like to note the severe
impact of the pandemic in residential care settings, with over 27% of COVID-19 deaths occurring in
nursing homes by 20233 ALONE will provide a separate submission on this topic when that
consultation arises. In this submission, we share key lessons learned in three priority areas:
Relationships, Social Connection and Community; Mental Health and Well-Being; and Physical
Health.

We hope our experience and insights will support the Evaluation Panel in developing a
comprehensive and accurate account of Ireland’s strategy and response to COVID-19.
Please let us know if we can provide further information or documentation to assist your work.

Kind regards,

Dr Aileen O’ Reilly Alexis Henning-FitzGerald
Head of Research, Evaluation and Policy Research, Evaluation and Policy Officer


CHY 8259
RCN 20020057

Relationships, Social Connection and Community

Loneliness and Social Connection:

Loneliness is a significant issue which affects older people and many other cohorts across Ireland. In
2024, loneliness was the second highest reported concern among older people referred to ALONE4.
At a national level, TILDA research has found that one-third of all adults aged 50+ report feeling
lonely at least some of the time5. People who experience prolonged loneliness and social isolation
are significantly more likely to present with additional physical health issues. For example, loneliness
has been linked to an increased risk of early death, with some studies highlighting that older people
experiencing high levels of loneliness are twice as likely to die within six years compared to those
who are not lonely.6 Further studies have linked loneliness and social isolation to higher risks of
physical and mental difficulties, including heart disease, anxiety, depression, and Alzheimer’s
disease7.

The COVID-19 pandemic exacerbated the numbers of people over 65 who felt lonely, due to the
unprecedented social distancing and ‘cocooning’ policies that were put in place to limit the spread of
the virus8.
.Although cocooning measures were initially put in place with the intention of
safeguarding the health and wellbeing of older people, the long-term effects of loneliness and social
isolation may not have been sufficiently recognised and addressed. In 2020, ALONE and TILDA
published a report which considered the impacts of loneliness and public health measures on people
over 709 and highlighted that public policies should be developed to address these. ALONE also
released a press release warning of the physical and mental health impacts of cocooning10
,encouraging Government to consider the possible long-term ramifications of the policy on health
and wellbeing.

Like many other services, ALONE had to adapt its in-person Support and Befriending services
(whereby volunteers provide regular visits to an older person, providing friendship, practical support
and links to local activities and initiatives) during the pandemic, so that the increasing number of
older people experiencing loneliness could still receive support, while also ensuring our services
were compliant with COVID-19 measures. Prior to the pandemic, ALONE volunteers were able to
visit older people in their homes. During the pandemic, ALONE adapted to making telephone calls
and providing practical supports where we could, including making onward referrals to other
services for older people who called in about their mental or physical health needs. Thanks to the
increased levels of staffing, volunteers, and financial support from the community who came
together to support the rapid increase in calls from older people, we were able to successfully
deliver 136,966 Support and Befriending phone calls throughout 2020, an increase of 40% on the
previous year with 2,426 unique older people receiving a call each week.


Once cocooning measures were relaxed, ALONE welcomed the ‘Hello Again World’ campaign run by
the Department of Health and Healthy Ireland in 202311 to encourage older people to return to their
lives after the primary threat of COVID-19 had passed. The campaign encouraged older people to
reconnect with their communities to avoid loneliness and isolation. At the time, however, many day
care centres, rural transport and social activities had not resumed normal operations, even though
COVID-19 restrictions had been lifted 12(see Relationships and Community for more information on
the closure of community services). ALONE advocated at Government level for the return of these
services, urging Government to consider a re-emergence plan for older people.13

Unfortunately, although levels of loneliness have decreased in the years following the pandemic,
rates have not returned to pre-2020 levels across all age groups in Ireland14
. Ireland has never implemented a dedicated policy or national plan specifically addressing
loneliness; however, the issue has been acknowledged in government policies and documents,
including the Programme for Government, the Healthy Ireland Strategic Plan, and the Roadmap
for Social Inclusion. ALONE believes that a dedicated national strategy to tackle loneliness would
represent an important step toward addressing the issue among older people in Ireland. Such an
action plan would have been especially valuable in the immediate aftermath of the COVID-19
restrictions, providing targeted support to older people and other groups most affected by the
isolation and loneliness brought about by the pandemic.

The negative impacts of loneliness can be mitigated with community level supports. Between
September 2018 and June 2021, ALONE and the Health Research Board (HRB) developed an
evaluation of our Support and Befriending Service in the Befriending, Loneliness and Health Report.
This research demonstrated that engaging in the intervention was associated with less decline
in health-related quality of life, indicating the service can have a therapeutic effect on health.15
Additionally, ALONE’s recent Impact Evaluation Transforming Ageing at Home found reduced
loneliness, improved quality of life, decreased reliance on emergency departments and community
healthcare services, and increased personal capability and older people supported by our services.

Based on our learnings, ALONE and the Loneliness Taskforce, which works to increase awareness of
the problem and to produce a set of recommendations for Government, state agencies and all policy
makers, 16 have urged the Government to adopt the following policy recommendations, drawn
specifically from the experiences and lessons of the pandemic.

Recommendations:

  • Develop a comprehensive cross-sectoral strategy to address loneliness and support social
    connection, and appoint a Minister to lead on the implementation.
  • Develop a public awareness and education campaign on loneliness at a national level to
    improve loneliness health literacy.
  • Establish a community-focused grant funding scheme to enable social connection and
    combat loneliness at a local level (estimated cost: €4m)17
    .
    Relationships and Community:
    The report by the Age Alliance, Telling It Like It Is: What Older People Told Us About their Experience
    of Covid-19, and What Ireland Should Do About It 18 , outlines the impact of cocooning on the lives
    of older people: on their experiences in their communities, their physical and mental health, and their
    social lives. The report found that older people‘s social contacts were heavily affected by the closure
    of social spaces such as clubs, cafes and other activities. Social engagement and connection are key
    to positive ageing, and this was heavily fractured during the lockdowns, particularly for the “older
    old” and those who do not use the internet or social media.

    A clear example of this impact was seen in the closure of day care centres. Older people, especially
    those who are widowed, disabled, or living alone, rely on these centres not only for care and support
    but also for a sense of community. As of August 2023, there were 323 HSE funded day care centres
    in operation in Ireland.19 Evaluations indicate that 75% of attendees are over the age of 75,
    representing 5.4% of Ireland’s population in that age group.

    Day care centres were heavily affected during and after the COVID-19 restrictions, with many
    remaining closed for extended periods even after restrictions were lifted20. In some cases, staff had
    been redeployed to other roles, such as COVID-19 testing centres, and replacing them took
    considerable time21. As of 2025, closures continue due to insufficient funding to meet new health
    and safety standards, reflecting long-standing structural underfunding22
    . Some attempts have been made by Government to address this, including an additional
    €10 million allocated to day care centres in Budget 2024. (23) Despite these efforts, day care
    centres remain largely unregulated, and the adequacy of funding has yet to be properly assessed.
    These centres continue to be an invaluable resource, helping older people maintain connections with their communities.

    In addition, during periods when restrictions eased, the lack of COVID-19 compliant public transport
    for older people exacerbated difficulties being experienced by older people as they began to reengage.
    For many, this resulted in missed medical appointments or required the use of expensive
    taxi services.24 This resulted in older people not only missing out on community social experiences
    such as in restaurants or cafes, but unable to access basic services such as grocery shopping or
    pharmacies.

    The critical role of the community

    As well as the challenges experienced throughout this time, we believe it is important to recognise
    the exceptional mobilisation of our communities who volunteered to support older people during
    the pandemic restrictions. ALONE volunteers mobilised to distribute food, medication and solid fuel
    to older people, resulting in 14,000 practical supports successfully delivered by volunteers and
    ALONE Support Coordinators in the month of April 2020 alone. As restrictions eased later in 2020,
    volunteers also participated in outdoor visits and walks with older people, though many older
    people struggled with the lack of accessible, walkable green spaces.

    ALONE received an overwhelming response from the public looking to volunteer. Building on the
    learnings from the rapid increase in volunteer interest, ALONE streamlined its recruitment and
    training processes, introducing faster and more efficient online self-learning modules during 2020.
    By the end of the year, all ALONE telephone services were operating at full capacity with volunteer
    support.

    The uptick in community participation proved to be a vital resource for many older people, many of
    whom reached out to ALONE as they did not have family members locally to support them. Without
    this significant level of community support, the impacts of cocooning may have been even more
    severe on older people. The role of the community and voluntary sector in providing necessary
    support such as grocery and medication deliveries, as well as social supports, brought the critical
    role of organisations and volunteers in providing essential services into sharp relief.


    Based on these learnings, ALONE has the following policy recommendations:
  1. Improve Day Care provision. In line with the 2025 Programme for Government commitment
    to enhance our network of day centres, Government should develop and implement a
    sustainable model for day care services for older adults in Ireland. This model should ensure
    access to high-quality care, meaningful social engagement, and support with daily living
    activities, and should include development of a system of regulation, and a review of capital
    infrastructure needs.
  2. Provide integrated funding for transportation as an element of the day care service and
    provide a clear funding mechanism for this. ALONE’s 2026 Pre-Budget Submission25 calls for
    €20m in transport funding to day care centres from the Department of Health.
  3. Increase funding and support for community and voluntary sector organisations by €60m,
    as recommended by ALONE and Social Justice Ireland26


    Mental Health and Wellbeing
    Older people’s mental health is an increasingly important issue that does not get the attention it
    deserves. The levels of unmet mental health needs amongst older people are extremely high and
    improving current services is critical. Indeed, TILDA has found that 78% of older adults who have
    evidence of depression, and 85% who have evidence of anxiety do not have a doctor’s diagnosis27
    Older people often experience mental health difficulties due to major life changes such as being
    widowed, the onset of physical illness, disability and bereavement28
    .
    COVID-19 worsened mental health and wellbeing among older adults, particularly because most
    deaths occurred within their age group. Many faced deepened depression as they dealt with the
    sudden loss of spouses or family members, leaving them newly widowed and grieving.
    29 ALONE observed a rise in calls to our National Support and Referral Line (NSRL) from older people
    who were living alone and those experiencing suicidal ideation during the pandemic30
    . Similarly, the HSE found that hospital-presenting suicide-related ideation increased in older people by
    27% in the first two years of the pandemic.31

    Despite the clear need, mental health services for older people are inadequate. Many mental health
    professionals receive little training in older age issues and feel unprepared to address them. A
    literature review found that ageism contributes to low interest in older person’s services for
    graduating psychologists32 leading to fewer specialists and more unmet needs. The Mental Health
    Commission’s 2020 report underscored these service gaps33, noting that no region met the
    recommended number of dedicated acute mental health beds for older people, and provision was
    only 50% of that recommended by A Vision for Change. The HSE’s Model of Care for Specialist
    Mental Health Services for Older People (MHSOP), launched in 2019, outlined care pathways,
    training standards, and governance structures, but its implementation has stalled due to severe
    staffing shortages. 34

    These shortages have persisted – and in some cases worsened – since the pandemic. According to
    HSE data published by Sinn Fein, 21,132 people were waiting on primary care psychology services as
    of February 2024, a 102% increase from 2020.35 Of this number, 2,564 were adults, although it is
    unclear how many are over the age of 65.

    ALONE services have played an important role in protecting older people’s mental health. As noted
    in earlier sections, ALONE’s recent impact evaluation36 confirmed that our supports reduced
    loneliness, improved quality of life and strengthened personal capability.

    Older people’s mental health remains critically underserved, even as demand rises. Community
    based supports such as ALONE’s programmes clearly improve wellbeing, but they are not a
    substitute for properly staffed specialist mental health services.
    Therefore, ALONE has the following recommendations to improve
    mental health services for older people:

    1: Fully Implement the Model of Care for Older People to ensure comprehensive,
    evidence-based services are available nationwide.

    2: Expand mental health supports tailored to older adults, ensuring services are
    accessible, age-appropriate, and responsive to their unique needs.

    3: Expand acute mental healthcare capacity for older adults, considering the significant
    shortages. In our Pre-Budget Submission 2026, ALONE called for €25.6m to support
    mental health beds and staffing issues37
    .

    Physical Health
    As people age, a natural decline in physical health is common. TILDA has identified several key
    health issues facing older adults. These include cardiovascular diseases (e.g., hypertension, stroke),
    non-cardiovascular chronic conditions (e.g., diabetes, sensory impairment) and chronic respiratory
    diseases. In addition, issues such as obesity, polypharmacy (use of multiple medications), cancer and
    falls are significant and growing health concerns.38

    The COVID-19 pandemic intensified these risks. Research from ALONE and TILDA found that
    cocooning measures led to an increase in calls to ALONE’s National Support and Referral Line (NSRL)
    from older people experiencing physical pain, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), and
    diabetes-related issues39. Further research has shown that cocooning measures meant older peopl
    spent more time indoors, leading to less physical activity, increased screen use, poorer sleep, higher
    stress, more frequent snacking and lower protein intake, increasing the risk of developing these
    diseases40 The lack of sun exposure also resulted in less Vitamin D, further affecting health 41.
    Indeed, according to the CSO, 42% of deaths in Ireland due to COVID were in those aged 85 and
    over, 75% in people aged 75 and over and 91% in people aged 65 and over42

    Several reports have since criticised elements of the cocooning measures and associated public
    communication, describing them as unnecessarily broad and potentially ageist43, which treated all
    older people as being the same regardless of the diversity of personal situations, capacities, health
    statuses, and needs that exist among this broad group. Nonetheless, 60% of participants in a TILDA
    study reported that they agreed with government advice regarding cocooning44.
    .
    Many older adults delayed or avoided medical treatment during the pandemic. In the TILDA study
    cited above, almost 1 in 6 of study participants reported that while cocooning they did not seek
    medical attention for an illness, when they otherwise would have done so45
    . ALONE and TILDA research highlighted an increase in callers to ALONE reporting postponed
    check-ups or treatment, even after falls. Half of those who did not seek medical attention said this
    was because they were afraid of catching COVID-19.46 At the same time, limited appointment
    availability meant that even
    those who tried to access care often could not, with insufficient numbers of GPs to meet demand47.
    .
    The HSE’s Enhanced Community Care (ECC) Programme has shown how shifting care to the
    community can ease hospital strain. During the pandemic, ECC services increased patient contacts
    by 31.5% and successfully supported over 7,000 frail adults which prevented unnecessary hospital
    admissions. ALONE believes that ageing well depends on more than medical treatment. Equitable
    access to primary care, integrated community services, and preventative measures to reduce frailty
    and falls are vital to maintaining quality of life and preparing for future public health crises. Drawing
    on the lessons from the pandemic’s impact on older people’s physical health, ALONE proposes the
    following policy recommendations:

    1: Invest in Fall Prevention through Community Exercise Programmes: As recommended by
    ALONE and Social Justice Ireland, the roll out of fall prevention programmes can support
    older people to age well at home (estimated 2026 cost: €1.7m)
    48
    .
    2: Invest in Primary Care Services: Increasing the number of GP practice teams across the state
    will strengthen Primary Care services, ensuring timely access to care and reducing overreliance on hospital care services (estimated 2026 cost: €100m)
    49
    .


    Footnotes
  4. 1 https://assets.gov.ie/static/documents/the-community-call-advice-and-contact-information-for-your-county-6c3f0617- bc92-4bde-b.pdf
    2 https://www.gov.ie/ga/roinn-an-taoisigh/preaseisiuinti/covid-19-public-information-booklet-to-be-delivered-to-everyhousehold-nationwide/
    3 Over 27% of Covid-19 deaths were in nursing homes
    4 ALONE-ECC-Report-2024.pdf
    5 https://tilda.tcd.ie/publications/reports/pdf/Report_Loneliness.pdf
    6 Ye Lou, Hawkley LC, Waite LJ et al. Loneliness, health and mortality in old age: A national longitudinal study. Soc Sci Med 2012; 74,pp. 907-914
    7 https://www.nia.nih.gov/news/social-isolation-loneliness-older-people-pose-health-risks
    8 https://tilda.tcd.ie/publications/reports/pdf/Report_Covid19SocialIsolation.pdf
    9 https://tilda.tcd.ie/publications/reports/pdf/Report_Covid19SocialIsolation.pdf
    10 ALONE warns that cocooning will have a long term impact on the physical health and wellbeing of older people – ALONE
    11 https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-health/press-releases/ministers-and-chief-medical-officer-advise-older-peoplehow-to-reconnect-with-their-communities-as-they-launch-online-resource/
    12 https://alone.ie/alone-calls-for-long-awaited-national-strategy-to-combat-loneliness-in-light-of-hello-again-worldcampaign/
    13 ALONE urges Government to begin their plans towards a re-emergence programme for older and medically vulnerable groups – ALONE
    14 CSO Wellbeing Information Hub
    15 HALO Report
    16 A briefing from the Loneliness Taskforce (2024)
    17 Policy Options to Support Ageing Well at Home: Budget 2026
    18 https://alzheimer.ie/wp-content/uploads/2021/07/Telling-It-Like-It-Is.pdf
    19 https://www.hse.ie/eng/about/personalpq/pq/2023-pq-responses/july%202023/pq-35274-23-richard-bruton.pd
     20 https://www.rte.ie/news/coronavirus/2021/0519/1222604-sage-day-care/
    21 Elderly ‘forgotten’ as care centres closed since 2020 | Southern Star
    22 Dementia sufferers are unable to return to their day care as centres are not yet Covid compliant | Irish Independent
    23 Ministers for Health announce €10 million in additional funding for Day Centres and Meals on Wheels community care services
    24 https://alone.ie/alone-raises-concerns-regarding-access-to-safe-public-transport-for-older-people/
    25 ALONE Pre-Budget 2026 Summary – ALONE
    26 Policies for Ageing Well at Home in Ireland’, ALONE and Social Justice Ireland, 2024
    27 https://tilda.tcd.ie/publications/reports/pdf/w1-key-findings-report/Chapter6.pdf
    28 https://tilda.tcd.ie/publications/reports/pdf/w1-key-findings-report/Chapter6.pdf
    29 Mental Health Issues Associated With COVID-19 Among the Elderly Population: A Narrative Review – PMC
    30 https://tilda.tcd.ie/news-events/2020/2024-covid19-loneliness-over70s/
    31 Patterns of Hospital Presenting Suicide-Related Ideation in Older Adults before and during COVID-19:
    32 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1041610224005052#:~:text=’Developmental%20psychol ogy’%20is%20often%20presented,in%20an%20old%20age%20service
    33 https://www.mhcirl.ie/sites/default/files/2021-01/Mental-Health-Services-for-Older-People-Report2020.pdf 34 https://www.hse.ie/eng/about/who/cspd/ncps/older-people/moc/specialist-mental-health-services-forolder-people-model-of-care.pdf
    35 Psychology waiting lists have doubled under this government – Mark Ward TD – Sinn Féin
    36 ALONE-IMPACT-ASSESSMENT-REPORT_FINAL.pdf
    37 ALONE Pre-Budget 2026 Summary – ALONE
    38 2025.06.24-Policies-for-Ageing-Well-at-Home-in-Ireland-Health-and-Wellbeing.pdf
  5. 39 Report_Covid19SocialIsolation.pdf
    40 https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33001410/
    41 interim-report-on-the-impact-of-cocooning-measures-on-older-people.pdf
    42 Covid-19: Nine out of 10 deaths among over-65s, CSO data finds – The Irish Times
    43 https://alzheimer.ie/wp-content/uploads/2021/07/Telling-It-Like-It-Is.pdf
    44 ‘Physical and Mental Health of Older People while Cocooning during the COVID-19 Pandemic’, https://academic.oup.com/qjmed/advance-article/doi/10.1093/qjmed/hcab015/6104561
    45 Ibid
    46 Findings reveal stark health impacts of ‘cocooning’ for older people – News & Events | Trinity College Dublin 
    47 Chronic shortage of doctors will have devastating implications if not addressed
    48 ’Policy Options to Support Ageing Well at Home: Budget 2026’, ALONE and Social Justice Ireland
    49 ‘Policy Options to Support Ageing Well at Home: Budget 2026’, ALONE and Social Justice Ireland